Showing posts with label Patent Troll. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Patent Troll. Show all posts

Friday, 23 September 2011

The Costs of the Trolls


Boston University researcher James E. Bessen has published a study with the title “The Private and Social Costs of Patent Trolls” on SSRN which evaluates the alleged costs due to lawsuits filed by a particular group of non-practicing entities identified by the oganization “Patent Freedom” as trolls.

The method comprises evaluating the impact on filing a lawsuit onto the stock market value of the defendant companies in a time window a few days after the filing of the lawsuit. PatLit finds it not surprising that the news of being accused of patent infringement is considered bad news on the stock exchange and that the stock exchange rates tend to decrease as a result. A little more surprising is the finding that this effect is much less pronounced when the plaintiff is one of the alleged trolls (as compared to the effect of being accused by a “regular” plaintiff). Lawsuits filed by trolls generate a mean loss of 0.32%, whereas other studies have shown that the news of an ongoing patent litigation lead to losses of around 1.5% to 2% in the stock exchange rate.

Whilst the author’s definition of trolls as individuals “who opportunistically litigate over software patents with unpredictable boundaries” appears to divest a mind which is not completely unbiased, PatLit - as an impartial organ of the administration of justice - has to insist on the presumption of innocence and thinks that at least a fraction of the alleged damages might be due to patent infringements committed by the defendants, for which the poor trolls are not to blame.

Tuesday, 28 June 2011

US Patent reform: fears to changes

I was planning what to do during last warm long weekend in Madrid when I realised that the America Invents Act passed in Congress with a vote of 304-117.

Much has been said in the last days about the inconvenience of this reform. Most of the comments I have read refer to its negative impact. Some of those describe drastically the effects. How does it look if we put some of them together?

“The anti-innovation patent reform act of 2011” “creates strong financial incentives for usurping patent rights by hacking and industrial espionage”, “could end up making it more difficult for inventors to defend their patents against infringement” and would be “dangerous to U.S. Security”.

Not bad, write?

Changes always cause fear. Modification of the system means that the new regime will have to be studied, bring some uncertainty and most of the times have economic effects (this Act has also been called the “job-killing Patent-Bill”).

I prefer trying to see the benefits and among those, the comment that brings the attention of this Patlit is the “attempt to keep patent battles out of the courts”. How this would happen? Damages regulation may have an important role. According to the Executive summary published in the website of the Republican Majority in Congress (here) “only a person who suffers a competitive injury as a result of false marking may bring a civil action in federal court for compensatory damages”. If this is correct, what would be the future of Patent Trolls?

If you want to read what do politicians say, you may like to read "The America Invents Act - Promoting American Innovation, Creating American Jobs, Growing America's Eeconomy" (here) (pdf alert)

In any case, experience show that changes are very rarely as bad (neither as good) as seemed.

We’ll see who is right.

What do you think?